Ethiqs | Legal update | 18 November 2026

For clients litigating in the Gauteng High Court, mediation should form part of the strategy from the outset and not an afterthought when a trial date is needed. This has been confirmed in recent cases where parties have unsuccessfully attempted to bypass the mandatory mediation directive.

The framework: civil trials in Gauteng, not every court proceeding

Mediation is often thought of as a voluntary framework for dispute resolution. Since 22 April 2025, the Directive from the (then) Judge President of the Gauteng High Court has made mediation a compulsory component of litigating in the Gauteng High Court. This was implemented in the hope of reducing the severe backlog in the civil trial roll. The directive mandates that no litigant is able to obtain a trial date unless the request is accompanied by a mediator's report. The effect of this is that mediation has now been institutionalised and needs to form part of the legal strategy from the outset.

The directive is only applicable to the Gauteng High Court. Importantly, the mediation directive allows courts to dispense with Uniform Rule 41A, which requires parties to new actions and applications to serve notices indicating whether they agree to or oppose mediation, with reasons. Civil litigation, including commercial, family and personal-injury disputes, in both divisions (Johannesburg and Pretoria) must first go through mediation before a matter can proceed to trial.

Notably, matters certified for the Commercial Court have a specific reporting arrangement, while transitional arrangements affect existing trial dates. Litigants should check their allocations rather than assume an old date is secure, or that mediation only becomes relevant on 1 January 2027.

Mandatory participation does not mean compulsory settlement

The Mediation Protocol requires parties to engage constructively, not to settle. The mediator facilitates discussion but cannot impose an outcome. Any settlement must be recorded in writing and signed by the parties; if mediation fails, it can still narrow the issues for trial. Organisational litigants must attend through properly authorised representatives with settlement authority.

Our practical recommendation is to assess the evidence, establish a realistic negotiating range and obtain internal approvals before the session, rather than sending someone who can discuss a resolution but cannot authorise it.

Can a party be excused from mediation?

Yes, but not simply because a party doubts mediation will work.

In Brondani v Brondani [2025] ZAGPJHC 1157, the court required exceptional circumstances; acrimony and subjective pessimism were not enough.

In Timmins N.O. and Another v Smith and Another [2026] ZAGPJHC 583, the court excused further mediation of a narrow legal dispute but ordered attorney-and-client costs for unjustified resistance. Timmins also confirms that, under the protocol, parties can set out why mediation is unsuitable in a joint minute, formulate the legal or factual dispute and approach the Umpire if they disagree.

The key distinction is between a justified request to proceed without mediation and a blanket refusal to engage.

The constitutional challenge: no decision on the merits

The mediation directive has already faced its first constitutional challenge in the Gauteng High Court, in Personal Injury Lawyers' Association and Others v Judge President of the Gauteng Division of the High Court and Others [2026] ZAGPPHC 783. However, the case failed on a procedural ground: the applicants had not obtained the required consent before instituting proceedings against the Judge President. The court declared the proceedings a nullity and dismissed the application. Significantly, this judgment did not decide whether compulsory mediation as a condition of trial enrolment is constitutionally valid. The judgment has been taken on appeal, but the mediation directive remains in force, which was also confirmed in the Timmins case.

What clients should do now

Our practical recommendation is to:
  • Audit the timetable: check existing trial dates, reporting requirements and the operative court directions.
  • Engage on the real dispute: identify what remains contested and what could be resolved or narrowed.
  • Prepare to negotiate: assemble essential documents, budget for the process and secure meaningful settlement authority.
  • Raise suitability concerns properly: use the recognised process rather than simply refusing to participate.
  • Verify before enforcing: do not treat a reported proposal as permission to bypass an existing procedural step.

The commercial objective should remain resolution or a shorter, more focused trial, rather than another round of litigation about mediation itself.

If mediation is about to become part of your litigation timetable, book a free 20-minute call with the Ethiqs team.

This update seeks to provide general information and does not constitute advice on a particular dispute.

Book a free 20min Chat

Feel free to ask for details, don't save any questions!

Our Office

Business Hours

  • Monday - Friday - 9am to 5pm

Get in Touch

Ethiqs is committed to providing our clients with accessible, transparent and affordable legal services and this starts all the way from the initial consultation.